Amazon has the Almay 24 Hour All Day Waterproof Intense Gel Eyeliner (110 Rich Black) for $4.25 - $1.42 off coupon (click "Save an extra" box) - 5% off with Subscribe & Save (can cancel anytime) = $2.62 with free shipping on $25+ or with Prime (extra 15% off for 5+ S&S orders).